Lyle, a man Fay met while on vacation comes to the island to court her. He proposes to her and they were in the process of getting married when the minister utters his full name. That's when Fay freaks out, because he has the same name as her other dead husbands. She then goes to Joe who is nursing a cold to ask him what she should do.
Stars: Tim Daly, Steven Weber, Crystal Bernard
Director(s): Jeff Melman
Writer(s): David Angell, Peter Casey, David Lee